Originally published in Interactions, Vol. 19,
No. 3, 2001
by Ed Kane
From their earliest years, animals fascinate healthy
children. Dogs, cats, rabbits, and birds – their movements, sounds,
nature, their softness, and often cuddliness are attractive to most kids.
Animals provide more than stimulation to kids. It seems they have an
intrinsic value in sharing affection, feelings, and defraying fear.
Ill, infirm, hospitalized kids seem to benefit from that
same stimulation and bonding.
Though we believe animals seem to bestow this value, it
has been argued that although animal-assisted therapy is widespread, it
may or may not have significant benefit. Critics explain (Beck & Katcher,
1984; Mallon, 1992) that there is a lack of high-quality research with
quantitative data to back up the claims. Mallon (1992) stated that
"relatively few substantive, quantitative studies" and "an abundance of –
case studies – with no formal research design and no controls," exist.
Beck & Katcher (1984) suggested that more sophisticated,
hypothesis-testing research was needed.
A Wealth of Research
Delta agrees that more research is needed and since
these criticisms were made, more studies have been published. Recent
research and the action and affection of animals in everyday settings,
seem to point not only to the benefit of animals to children, but also to
a "sixth sense" that animals, from dogs to horses, have on the real needs
of kids.
Limond, Bradshaw, and Cormack, (1997) demonstrated in a
good scientific study that children with severe learning disabilities
(Down's Syndrome) were both more attentive and more responsive in the
presence of a real dog (in comparison to an inanimate toy dog). Hansen,
Messinger, Baun, and Megel (1999) in a quantified scientific study, found
that the presence of a companion dog could lower the behavioral distress
of children during a laboratory-stimulated physical examination. They
suggested that companion animals might be useful in a variety of
healthcare settings to decrease procedure-induced distress in children.
Woolverton studied the responses of children to the
presence of an animal during neuromuscular examination. She observed, "It
is apparent to all who have participated that having an animal as part of
the clinic has provided a great deal of help to patient and staff alike."
In an anecdote from her study, a dog is introduced to a young girl crying
as a doctor manipulates her stiff legs. The affectionate dog snuggles up
to her on the exam table. "It really doesn't matter now [to the child]
what is going on at the other end of her body as long as this warm,
friendly dog is close to her," Woolverton noted.
Therapy Animals Answer the Call
Cathy
Bones, Pet Therapy Coordinator, Shriners Hospital for Children, Sacramento
CA, feels the response of kids to animals daily. Tommy, a 9-year-old burn
patient, a smart, courageous child, though pained from his injuries, "is
always glad to see the animals," Bones remarks. "He loves dogs, he misses
his" (which was lost in the fire that maimed Tommy). "He will come and
play with whatever dog is brought to him. Sometimes he just wants to sit
and stroke the dog, whispering his secrets to the dog. He says that the
dogs don't care about his face and try to lick his face through the mask
he wears to prevent scar tissue from forming."
John, a 6-year-old, with bilateral radial displasia (the
bones of his forearm are diminished) enjoys Scooch the Pooch. Though some
people are uncomfortable around John, Scooch, a basset hound, "adores
being touched by John, rolling over so that he can more easily reach her
tummy," Bones notes. John spent about 45 minutes petting and stroking
Scooch, telling everyone who came into the clinic area, "look, she likes
it – she likes ME!"
Carlos, an 8-year-old patient, is almost beside himself
when Butterfly, a 20-lb. lop rabbit, visits. He hugs, kisses and cuddles,
while chattering nonstop in Spanish. Katie, another young patient, wrote
of her experiences with dogs at the hospital. "These dogs were so well
behaved … I think my favorite dog was Abby, a Shih Tzu. She gave me lots
of kisses. All of these dogs made me feel so much better – I think for me
it was the best medicine of all. This is a great program – you'll never
know how much I enjoyed my visits from the dogs."
Service Animals Make a Difference
Service
animals help kids at home too. Linda Jennings, Loving Paws Assistance Dogs™,
Santa Rosa CA, relates a story of one of her clients.
"A high-school graduate with spinal cord injury has a
service dog, a Golden Retriever-Border Collie mix, named Rosie. One night
as the girl slept, a huge storm knocked out the power, which disabled the
intercom between her parents' room and hers. The girl needed her mother so
she sent her service dog to get her. Rosie first turned on the girl's
bedroom light, opened her door, and then proceeded to turn on the lights
along the way upstairs to get Mom. Mom's door was shut so Rosie opened the
door, turned on the bedroom light and licked Mom's face until she awoke.
Mom was surprised to see the lights on as she ran downstairs to see what
her daughter needed."
This mother was initially just expecting the service dog
to be a companion for her daughter. In reality, Rosie gives Mom peace of
mind. She's comfortable running errands, leaving her daughter home alone,
knowing that Rosie can get her out of the house in an emergency.
While more research takes place on the value of animals
to children, Scooch the Pooch, Abby, Rosie, and Butterfly, along with
their people partners, quietly and affectionately continue to do their
job.
Editor's Note:
For more information about Service Dogs and Children,
visit Loving Paws' web site at
www.lovingpaws.com.
Lower photo courtesy of Loving Paws.